Monday, September 17, 2012

Fallout Boy - Day Five

Bad day today... not so much from the radiation; I think I'm over the hard stuff from that; but I have got to get back on thyroid meds as soon as possible because I am dying here on the hypothyroid effects.

That and the money problems caused by this cancer are really kicking our ass today; but that's life.

Again, it's better than dying.

Date         Time HR D Dose 
9/17/2012 10:00 92 0 530
9/17/2012 10:00 92 2 19  
9/17/2012 10:00 92   3   6    
9/17/2012 10:00 92   6   1.9 
9/17/2012 10:00 92   12 1.1   
9/17/2012 14:00 96 0 485
9/17/2012 14:00 96 2 20  
9/17/2012 14:00 96 3 6    
9/17/2012 14:00 96 6 1.7 
9/17/2012 14:00 96 12 1    
9/17/2012 18:00 100 0 470
9/17/2012 18:00 100 2 17  
9/17/2012 18:00 100 3 5.8 
9/17/2012 18:00 100 6 1.5 
9/17/2012 18:00 100 12 0.8
9/17/2012 22:00 104 0 415
9/17/2012 22:00 104 2 16  
9/17/2012 22:00 104 3 4    
9/17/2012 22:00 104 6 1.7 
9/17/2012 22:00 104 12 0.9

At this point, the 3ft, 6ft, and 12ft distance measurements have become inconsistent. The environmental reflection, absorption, residual etc... are within the margin of measurement error, and the changes in background levels, so they're not going to be particularly accurate at this point.

I could average the errors out by taking five measurements, dropping the high and low, and averaging the middle three... but really that's too much hassle. the 3, 6, and 12 ft are all under 5 uSv/h at this point, which is in the safe zone for my wife, so I really don't care much. She can sit on the same couch with me; just at the opposite end. In a few days, she'll be able to sit next to me on the couch.

What's really important to me right now, is the torso contact measurement, which I'm measuring at the junction of neck and torso (a couple inches below my incision); the highest point of radiation concentration on my body (it falls quickly down to somewhere over 100 within a few inches, and between 20 and 60 over the rest of my body; higher in sensitive areas with lots of blood vessels, lower in extremities etc...).

Again, it's very clear the slope of change has shallowed dramatically; both hourly, and the 24hr day over day:

Distance -- 9/13 ------ 9/14 ----- 9/15 ----- 9/16 ----- 9/17
0                 >1000    >1000     790       580         485

2                 >1000    240           70       38          20  
3                 800        40            15       7            6    
6                 600        22           5.3       2.5         1.7 
12               480        9             2.4       1.1         1    


From differential scanning, around many areas of my body, that high toros contact number could indicate that I've still got a large mass, or large concentration of cancerous tissue somewhere in my neck or upper chest. We'll know when they gamma cam me on Thursday.

That may indicate I need a second dose... We'll know better on Thursday... Or more likely Friday or Monday, after my endocrinologist and radiologist consult...

Or it could just mean the tissue is still dying and hasn't purged out enough yet. It has only been 105 hours since I was dosed after all.

We'll see.

Sunday, September 16, 2012

Fallout Boy - Day 4

Yay, no more medium hammers.

Small ones... but not medium ones.

Honestly, I'm feeling a heck of a lot better today. Still pretty weak and achy, particularly in the joints; but a lot better than yesterday. Also, the nausea is gone. 

Part of that may be I was finally able to get a little sleep. A whole uninterrupted six hours last night, which is more than I've been getting for the past few months. 

I'm still a little fuzzy and off mentally, and I still zoned out a few times today; but I was much more awake and alert than I have been. I've had a reasonable attention span as well. 

The downside, I actually kinda passed out for a nap in the middle of the day; and my temperature regulation is awful. My fingers and toes feel like they're freezing off, and I'm wrapped up in a blanket at 70 degrees.

Now, the numbers for the day:

Date         Time HR D Dose 
9/16/2012 10:00 68 0 620
9/16/2012 10:00 68 2 40  
9/16/2012 10:00 68 3 8    
9/16/2012 10:00 68 6 2.8 
9/16/2012 10:00 68 12 1.3   
9/16/2012 14:00 72 0 580
9/16/2012 14:00 72 2 38  
9/16/2012 14:00 72 3 7    
9/16/2012 14:00 72 6 2.5 
9/16/2012 14:00 72 12 1.1 
9/16/2012 18:00 76 0 540
9/16/2012 18:00 76 2 26  
9/16/2012 18:00 76 3 8    
9/16/2012 18:00 76 6 2    
9/16/2012 18:00 76 12 1.2 
9/16/2012 22:00 80 0 515
9/16/2012 22:00 80 2 21  
9/16/2012 22:00 80 3 7    
9/16/2012 22:00 80 6 2    
9/16/2012 22:00 80 12 1.1 

You'll note, the slope of change has shallowed dramatically; both hourly, and the 24hr day over day:

Distance -- 9/13 ------ 9/14 ----- 9/15 ----- 9/16
0                 >1000    >1000     790       580 

2                 >1000    240           70       38  
3                 800        40            15       7    
6                 600        22           5.3       2.5 
12               480        9             2.4       1.1 


My wife still can't sit with me, but there's no problem being in the same room with me or sitting NEAR me, all day long. We let the doggies in for a few minutes... Kinda hard to keep them from licking me.

I'm getting VERY tired of sitting/laying on a couch, watching reruns... but hey, it's better than... you know... dying and stuff.

Irrelevant Geeky Sidebar:

Actually, the wife and I have been using this whole thing, from pre-surgery 'til today; as an opportunity to watch the entire new run of Doctor Who (from the 9th Doctor on).

We had seen the 9th doctor (the first new series), but never picked up the 10th, because it was being played inconsistently in the U.S. As of today, we're up to the middle of series 3.

I still prefer Christopher Ecclestone. I know that's an unpopular choice, but I like his performance and his personality better than David Tennant (who I still thing is GREAT. Funny, charming, ALIVE as hell). Though surprisingly, they both beat my previous favorite, Tom Baker (my first Doctor, from PBS showings in the early 80s); which I thought was impossible.

After we finish Dr. Who, we're going to do Torchwood; which, again, we haven't watched at all. Maybe Warehouse 13 as well.

When she's not watching with me, I'm using the time to read/re-read some long series I haven't read in a while, to catch up on long podcasts, and to watch "24" from the beginning. I was living in Ireland when the show premiered, and I hate coming into a show in the middle of its run, so I never watched it.

I think I'll watch "lost" after I finish up "24"; and pick up season 3 and later of "Eureka".

Thank god for netflix.

If you are any kind of music fan at all

Or a Henry Rollins fan, or a serious workaholic, or a nutjob fan of any kind... This is the craziest most amazing podcast I've ever heard:


It's basically a 90 minute stream of consciousness from Henry Rollins, and a couple really big, really smart, fans of his and the music he is also a fan of. 

I was laughing my ass off the entire time, and just having my mind blown.

... But every time I hear Rollins do a spoken word performance, or do a long form show etc... He blows me away.

When people ask me how it is that I can write blog posts off the top of my head that take them an hour to read, I just tell them "that's just how I think. It comes off the top of my head like that, at a million miles an hour... "

I actually write like twice that much, typing it near as fast as I can think it; and then maybe I go back and revise it a couple times and clean it up, cut out the excessive or obscure detail, cut out the irrelevant 20% or 30%, clean up the language a little, add in the numbers and the images, and thats it... Takes me about as long to write it as it would to have it as a conversation. 

Well, my friends and I, this is what we sound like when we get going. It's just a mind walk all over the world. Anyone who has ever sat up with us at a get together (especially the Gunblogger rendezvous)... That's what this particular podcast was like. 

Anyone who's like that, even if I have no idea what they are talking about, even if I'm not even interested in the subject matter, I love the passion and the detail, and that you're really SEEING who these people are.

I just love it. 

Well worth the hour and a half... Frankly I'd listen to this for 8 hours and be bummed out when I had to stop. 

Saturday, September 15, 2012

Fallout Boy - Day 3


So... basically today sucked.

Oh wait, I said that already... Yesterday in fact.

Medium hammers, bag, beatings, nausea, pain, weakness etc... Not as bad for the most part, but still...

One thing I forgot to mention the last couple posts is that I have a complete lack of body temperature regulation. Fever, chills, and my extremities feel frozen off half the time. This is a known side effect of hypothyroidism, gets worse the more hypo you are, and is exacerbated by the radiation.

Yeah cancer still sucks.

Sleep... That would be nice. I had 3 hours of semi-awake semi-sleep, and an hour or two of zoned out not sleep.

HOWEVER, I ate some real food today, even had some coffee and a sweet baked good (from the local hippy bakery. No preservatives, conditioners etc...).

...and, by the 48 hour mark, the rad levels had dropped enough so that Mel could sit across the room from me; which is nice. Still not on the same side of the room, but at least close enough to "be with" each other.


I'm going to graph out a couple doses here from today:

Date -- Time -- Delta -- Distance -- Dose uSv/h

9/15      1000      44          0                  830
9/15      1000      44          2                  86
9/15      1000      44          3                  16
9/15      1000      44          6                  6.8
9/15      1000      44          12                2.7

9/15      1400      48          0                  790
9/15      1400      48          2                  70
9/15      1400      48          3                  15
9/15      1400      48          6                  5.3
9/15      1400      48          12                2.4

9/15      1600      52          0                  750
9/15      1600      52          2                  60
9/15      1600      52          3                  14
9/15      1600      52          6                  5.2
9/15      1600      52          12                2

9/15      2200      56          0                  680
9/15      2200      56          2                  43
9/15      2200      56          3                  13
9/15      2200      56          6                  3.7
9/15      2200      56          12                1.7


Since the levels were safe enough, we also had Mel some testing on residual items, my seating area etc... with me out in the yard so as not to effect the measurements.

Very interesting numbers actually... Much lower than I thought they would be, considering the elimination tests.  Oh and the difference in my open air distance readings immediate before and immediately after elimination, was generally about 5%, which I thought was interesting as well.

My first full measurement was at 1600 thursday, so comparing 24 hour intervals we see (0 is touching my torso, 2 is holding the meter at arms length):

Distance -- 9/13 ------ 9/14 ----- 9/15 
0                 >1000       >1000     790
2                 >1000       240         70
3                 800           40           15
6                 600           22           5.3
12               480           9             2.4

Again a substantial, and very nonlinear falloff. Not directly proportional, not very close to inverse square, or inverse cube, and not really on any kind of consistent or predictable trend line slope except "down".

Basically, as I said yesterday, from my own personal results, you can't make any linear regression analyses to plot future dose numbers with any kind of accuracy.

Ehhh, the wife can be in the same room with me, I'm happy with that for now... Sleeping together again is still a while away (still projecting over a week from the dose, though the line is inconsistent). Oh and tomorrow, it'll probably be OK for me to let the dogs in, so long as I don't let them lick me or lay on top of me.

Now as I mentioned, we did some testing on residuals. Yesterday I said this:
One thing that I've found the guidelines are overcautious on though, is your dishes, silverware, and disposable plates and cups. They're not taking on any significant radiation to dose back out; though admittedly it's only been a day, and dosages are cumulative. So with multiple uses over several days, it may build up. I'll test it. Same thing with the sheets, towels etc... 
That isn't to say these items aren't picking up some radiation, they certainly are; but it's not a lot, and they don't hold on to it long once out of my immediate presence.
Today we got some real numbers (doses for objects are over background baseline):


Date -- Time -- Delta -- Distance -- Dose uSv/h -- Object

9/15      1400      48          0                  9                   Handkerchief (used repeatedly)
9/15      1400      48          0                  2.27              Couch seating area (used constantly)
9/15      1400      48          0                  1                   Bedding (used for two days)
9/15      1400      48          0                  0.8                Laptop (used constantly)
9/15      1400      48          0                  0.4                Glass of water sitting for hours (used)
9/15      1400      48          0                  0.2                Plate (used repeatedly)
9/15      1400      48          0                  0.2                Spoon (used repeatedly)
9/15      1400      48          3                  1.02              Seating area at other end of couch
9/15      1400      48          6                  0.59              6 foot line from seat, open air, no objects
9/15      1400      48          9                  0.72              Closest seat on other couch across room
9/15      1400      48          12                0.71              12 foot line, open air but some objects in area
9/15      1400      48          15                15                 Toilet (used repeatedly)
9/13      1400        0          25                0.14              baseline 25ft from seating area before dose

9/15      1400      48          25                0.43              25ft from seating area 24 and 48hr after dose



The 25 foot away baseline reading was the same at both 24 and 48 hours. Long distance, not much emission hitting there, so a slow change is expected.

Essentially, items I was in direct contact with absorbed a bit, but less than I'd expected; particularly my sheets and blankets. I had only been off them for a few minutes when they were tested, and they still barely hit 1 uSv/h.

Bodily fluids dosed the most by FAR. The handkerchief I'd been blowing my nose with for two days absorbed four times as much as my seating/sleeping area, and 9 times as much as my bedding; and the toilet, even though it's 15 feet from my seating area, even a couple hours after use, and even after multiple flushes, absorbed 15 times as much as my bedding.

Items I was less than 6 feet away from, and may have briefly handled or used, but I wasn't in direct contact with for extended lengths of time, absorbed very little. Organic matter more than 6 feet away got a small dose above background, something like .2uSv/h; and inorganic matter more than six feet away seems to have retained almost nothing over background.

Certainly, it would be safe to have someone else wash dishes you had used... Though of course I don't recommend you disregard doctors orders and guidelines.

Now, I just hope I can get some sleep tonight. I'm braindead.

And that was day three...

10.2cm, a graphical illustration

So, a month ago, I had a 10.2cm (slightly flattened sphere,) malignant tumor removed from my neck.

Intellectually, it's easy to understand that's about 4"... but just exactly what does a 4" tumor look like?

Well, today, Mel was at the fruit stand, and they had some pretty big honey crisp apples; and she noticed one in particular.

As it happens, a 10.2cm tumor is almost exactly this big; in fact, mine was almost exactly this shape as well (within 3mm):


Ummm... that's pretty damn big.

Ok, so... how big is it actually, in comparison to my neck?

This big:



Holy...!!!

How in the hell...

Seriously, I intellectually knew that I had a 10.2cm tumor in there; but until I saw the apple up against my throat I never fully understood what that meant.

Damn...


Using Big Guns to Hunt Radioactive Zebra

Today I attempted to explain to an old friend exactly why Chris experiencing extreme side effects from the radioactive iodine is a GOOD thing. It's counterintuitive and the conversation reminded me of something we've yet to address on this blog.

We are extremely blessed in our choice of doctors. Our care team is simply incredible.

That's not an accident though. We spent years going through doctors, trying to find someone who understood what Chris was experiencing. Finding our care team was the result of perseverance and patience.

There's a saying in the medical community: "If you hear hoofbeats, think horses, not zebras."

Chris is a zebra. Currently he's a radioactive zebra.

If someone could make me a design of a radioactive zebra I'd have a shop up on Zazzle and be selling radioactive zebra t-shirts by the end of the day.

But anyway...

Finding doctors who understood that they might be looking for a zebra can be incredibly difficult. Our breakthrough came in getting a very young and fresh family doc, convincing him that he was out of his depth, and getting him to send us to specialists. Then we just didn't quit until we got to the right specialist.

This is nothing new to me. In 2004 my youngest brother Tim, 30 years old at the time, suffered complete kidney failure. Most of the time dialysis patients are older, diabetic, and non-compliant. Tim is younger, has no other medical issues, and is incredibly OCD. Dialysis diets are written for the non-compliant. Tim might be the only dialysis patient in the country that almost stopped his heart from lack of potassium in his diet. Finding him a doctor who understood him took time and patience.

Finding a doctor who understands Chris ended up being incredibly difficult as well.

Chris got up to 300lbs overweight at one point. Most people that are that overweight 1. are diabetic, 2. have blood pressure issues, 3. lie to their doctors about their diet and 4. are past middle age. Chris is 36, normal blood sugar, normal blood pressure, and tells the doctors the truth. Finding a doc who understood all of that took some doing.

What finally did it for us was dealing with a new physician's assistant doing the intake at the group endocrinology practice. He didn't believe Chris either but he had a list of things he "had to do"in order to make the head of the practice happy.

The PA is the one who found the tumor.

Suddenly Chris got "upgraded" as it were. His case reached the ears of the head of the endocrinology practice, a man who graduated from medical school at Yale in 1969. He's one of the most respected endocrinology and metabolism researchers in the country.

This doc HAD to have Chris as his patient.

When we first met him we didn't jump through all the hoops or spend forever listing his symptoms to unbelieving ears. He came fully ready to believe that Chris was a zebra.

When Chris said "Endocrinology is weird and no-one understands it" the doc said, "Yeah, that's why I like it."

I'm fully convinced our endocrinologist's next research paper will heavily feature Chris.

Funny thing about doctors who "get it" and like odd cases; they know other doctors who feel the same way. That's how Chris ended up with an orthopedist who saw a man in his mid-30's with knee pain and treated him according to his age. Which meant Chris ended up with drugs that worked, not drugs that are safe for the vast majority of orthopedic patients.

Between these two doctors and their willingness to treat Chris as a zebra, they quite honestly saved his life. They reduced his symptoms, reduced his pain, and reduced his weight.

Most doctors are afraid to "bring out the big guns" as it were. Most doctors are afraid of lawsuits, malpractice claims, and non-compliant patients accidentally killing themselves. These doctors dived into Chris's case, took a good look at both of us, determined that we're educated and intelligent patients, and treated us accordingly. They brought out the big guns because we could handle it.

Which brings us to awesome doc number 3, our second (and final) surgeon.

There are no words for how much I love this surgeon. Mostly because of what he did the day of the surgery.

We'd met him at the consult and he'd gotten his measure of us. He knew who we were, he figured us out.

Right before the surgery he came to see us in the prep area. There he gave us the option.

"If I go in there and think that a lobe of the thyroid can be saved, do you want me to save it? That would reduce your chances of damage to the parathyroids and limit your risk. If I go in and I don't think it looks malignant, I can just take out the tumor and leave the rest alone, it's up to you."

We told him to take the whole thing, that we were pretty sure it was malignant (given the growth rate), and that we didn't want him going under the knife again if the pathology comes back with bad news. Also, with me being pregnant, we didn't want to take any chances.

He told us the surgery would take about an hour. It took 2 1/2 hours. Twice he had a nurse call me in the waiting room to update me and tell me everything was going okay, once during and once as they were closing up.

When he came to talk to me in the waiting area he walked up to me grinning like the cat that got the canary.

That's far more reassuring than it sounds. When a surgeon is wearing the "I fought a tough battle and I kicked its ass" grin, you know the world is okay.

He didn't withhold details from me. He'd already figured out that I could handle it.

He still didn't think it looked malignant, but he'd followed our wishes. Also, it was one of the largest masses he had seen, with the most extensive vascular network he had seen. He'd brought out the big guns.

Good thing too, as nine days later he's the one who delivered the bad news about the pathology (it was aggressively malignant; and without removal Chris could have been dead within a few months), and that Chris would be undergoing aggressive, high dose radioactive iodine ablation. He then passed the football back to our awesome endocrinologist.

Our awesome endocrinologist who, at the RAI consult, decided to keep bringing the big guns. He believed us when we told him we were already on a pretty low-iodine diet and had already stopped the thyroid supplementation in preparation for the treatment. He took us on our word, had a blood test run to confirm that Chris was ready, and had Chris booked for RAI by the end of the afternoon.

They usually wait six to eight weeks, just to make sure; but the doc understood how serious we were about nuking this bastard from orbit, and exactly one month after surgery Chris received his first RAI treatment. The minimum amount of time after surgery, the maximum dosage allowed for all but the most extreme life-threatening cases. We prepped to the max; not only did Chris adhere to a low-iodine diet, he went way past low-iodine requirements and made his body as desperate for iodine as possible.

It's not just the docs who get to bring out the big guns. Sometimes the patients can do that for themselves.

I can't state enough how unusual it is for doctors and patients to agree on going all-out, much less putting it into practice. It's almost unheard of. Usually both sides are much more cautious, would rather extend treatment than risk bad side effects or collateral damage.

Clearly Chris isn't a normal patient, and these aren't normal doctors.

Using the big guns does have a few drawbacks. Chris is incredibly sick; he's so hypothyroid and soaked up so much radiation that we weren't really prepared for how bad he'd feel.

Incredibly sick is a good sign. A sign that we maximized the amount of the RAI he'd soak up, and a sign that there's not much thyroid tissue left to cause a problem. This is one case where being really sick means you did something right.

In another week he'll undergo the full-body gamma camera scan to see where the RAI soaked up and identify any other masses that need to be removed. If that's clear or mostly clear (small spots will be cleared up over the next 6 months as the RAI clears his system) treatment will be considered successful. If there are a lot of specks remaining, large concentrations of specks, or any clear masses; they'll wait a few weeks for the remaining I-131 to clear his system, then dose him again, and scan him again.

They'll scan him again in six months to check for any other masses or concentrations of specks, and there's a chance he'll need to go for another treatment; but if the treatment was aggressive enough in the first place, it's unlikely (then he'll have to get a scan once a year for the rest of his life).

If treatment was successful the endocrinologist will start the thyroid hormone replacement regimen and start tinkering with dosages. He won't be starting at the normal "safe" starting point either; he's willing to calculate dosage according to what he knows about Chris and try to get the dose right the first time (400mcg per day; about four times the normal starting dose). He'll still be bringing out the big guns.

This is what happens when you're an educated patient, you find the right doctors, and you're willing to take some risks in order to get it done right the first time.

Being willing to take chances, using the big guns, and finding the right doctors is what it takes sometimes.

Especially if you happen to be a radioactive zebra.

Mel

Friday, September 14, 2012

Fallout Boy - Day two

So... basically today sucked.

As I have often said before in these pages, Cancer sucks, I highly recommend not getting it.

I'm not sure if it's the extreme hypothyroidism, the radiation, or the mixture of the two; but I pretty much feel like I've been stuffed into a burlap sack and severely beaten with medium sized hammers.

Why medium sized?

Because they hurt a lot, but don't break anything, and no one hit, is enough to distract you from all the others.

The nausea isn't actually bad (I've been able to eat, drink, and keep everything down), but the joint swelling, aches, headaches, muscle weakness, and general malaise... Not fun.

Honestly, I'm having a hell of a time getting up, moving around etc... Seriously, I'm weak as a damn kitten right now. Grunting when I pick up my laptop, and needing to brace myself and push off with my arms just to get off the couch.

I'm kinda uncoordinated and fuzzy too. I presume thats from the hypothyroid.

One thing I KNOW is from the hypothyroid is that lovely combination of extreme fatigue with inability to sleep. I managed a not very solid 3 hours last night (or rather, this morning. 5am to 8am) even though I was exhausted. I tried to nap twice during the day, and managed to zone out for a half hour or so each time, but couldn't actually sleep.

I'm fuzzing out, and getting foggy, quite a lot.

So, that's all the subjective bad news. 

The good news, is that the radiation is falling off pretty fast. So much so that Mel will be able to sit in the same room with me tomorrow.

I'm going to graph out a couple doses here from today:

Date -- Time -- Delta -- Distance -- Dose uSv/h

9/14      0800      18          0                  >1000
9/14      0800      18          2                  360
9/14      0800      18          3                  65
9/14      0800      18          6                  26
9/14      0800      18          12                14


9/14      1200      22          0                  >1000
9/14      1200      22          2                  290
9/14      1200      22          3                  52
9/14      1200      22          6                  24
9/14      1200      22          12                13

9/14      1400      24          0                  >1000
9/14      1400      24          2                  260
9/14      1400      24          3                  45
9/14      1400      24          6                  23
9/14      1400      24          12                9


9/14      1600      26          0                  >1000
9/14      1600      26          2                  240
9/14      1600      26          3                  40
9/14      1600      26          6                  22
9/14      1600      26          12                9



9/14      2000      30          0                  970
9/14      2000      30          2                  210
9/14      2000      30          3                  34
9/14      2000      30          6                  17
9/14      2000      30          12                7


9/15      0000      34          0                  900
9/15      0000      34          2                  150
9/15      0000      34          3                  24
9/15      0000      34          6                  13
9/15      0000      34          12                6


You can see that I switched up to four hour data reporting, from 8am to midnight, with the notable (in bold) exception of the 1400 reading, that being 24 hours after my dose (I gathered every two hours, just because I had nothing better to do. It'll be in my spreadsheet and graphs at the end of the process)

Now, the first thing about this data is I can't say enough how strongly radiation falloff is correlated with frequency and volume of elimination. The more water I eliminated (actually mostly gatorade), the more radiation I eliminated. In fact I tested before and after, just to see the difference, and it was as much as a 10% in less than five minutes. Since all my previous measurements were post elimination, I decided to make all of them post elimination. Also it's clear that the longer you go between eliminations, irrespective of volume, the greater the dosage in the elimination.

A few things are notable about these results.


  • The slope of change shallows out very quickly.  When you see the graphs, it's going to be a very peaky curve.
  • On wakeup at 8am, general radiation levels had fallen about 20-30% from the 2am measurement; and were less than half what they had been 12 hours earlier at 8pm.
  • At the 24 hour mark, I was still showing over 1000uSv/h touching my torso (I was at 1600 immediately after dosage); but otherwise the radiation  levels at 2, 3, 6, and 12 feet were all less than 15% what they had been after my first full measurement.
  • Also, the 24 hour mark was where I first fell below 10uSv/h at 12 feet; the maximum recommended long term dosage for healthy non-pregnant adult; just barely, but below. Some time tomorrow I'll fall below 5uSv/h at 12 feet, the maximum for my pregnant wife; and below 10uSv/h at 6ft. 

My first full measurement was at 1600 yesterday, so comparing 24 hour intervals we see (0 is touching my torso, 2 is holding the meter at arms length):

Distance -- 9/13 ------ 9/14 ----- %change
0                 >1000       >1000     UNK
2                 >1000       240         UNK
3                 800           40           95%
6                 600           22           96.5%
12               480           9             98.1%

That's a very substantial, and very nonlinear falloff. It's also not directly proportional, not very close to inverse square, and not really on any kind of consistent or predictable trend line slope except "down".

Basically, from my own personal results, you can't make any linear regression analyses to plot future dose numbers with any kind of accuracy.

That said, it looks like it'll be safe for my wife to sit across the room from me early tomorrow (Saturday), and probably 6ft away from me late tomorrow. Unfortunately, it probably won't be 'til Monday or tuesday she can sit on the other side of the couch from me; and it probably won't be for a couple days after that she can sit next to me on the love seat.

As for sleeping together...

Well, I finally fell below 1000uSv/h touching my torso at about 8pm; but the slope of change is pretty shallow. We won't be able to sleep together until that dosage drops at least to 5uSv/h, and in theory it would be safer to wait til it drops below 1uSv/h (we tend to sleep pressed up against each other. Maximum exposure). At the slope I'm seeing right now... It's going to be at least a week... Probably more like two (the trend line is 12 days from dose to get under 5... but as I said above the trend lines are inconsistent).

Oh and you definitely want to be using your own toilet for at least a week as well. That change slope is very shallow too. At the 24 hour mark, I was still eliminating at over half the initial elimination dosage.

One thing that I've found the guidelines are overcautious on though, is your dishes, silverware, and disposable plates and cups. They're not taking on any significant radiation to dose back out; though admittedly it's only been a day, and dosages are cumulative. So with multiple uses over several days, it may build up. I'll test it. Same thing with the sheets, towels etc...

That isn't to say these items aren't picking up some radiation, they certainly are; but it's not a lot, and they don't hold on to it long once out of my immediate presence.

Metal objects however... If you carry change in your pocket during this process, you definitely don't want anyone taking it into a federal building for at least a couple weeks... maybe longer.

I'll have Mel do a residual test with me out of the room on m sleeping position, my laptop, the contents of my pockets etc...

And that was day two...







Thursday, September 13, 2012

Fallout Boy - Day One




So, I'm radioactive.

 On purpose.

 ... Aint that a kick in the head.

My regular readers can skip ahead to the section after this, unless you'd like a recap of the course of the cancer. I'm writing this up for other thyroid cancer fighters, who will be coming to this page without having read me before.

So, once more unto the breach my friends...

The story so far...

For those of you just tuning in to our show, your humble narrator has been suffering from unusual health problems with endocrine symptoms since sometime in 2004 (or probably before, but it started being noticeable in '04).

By late 2005 it was very clear something was wrong, but we couldn't find any cause. Basically, I had lots of symptoms of diseases I didn't have; and they got progressively worse and weirder.

I also went from a healthy and strong 285-295lbs, working out regularly with under 15% bodyfat; to a damn near crippled 497lbs at 57% bodyfat; and most of that weight was gained about 4 of those 7 years

...and doesn't include the losing 70, then gaining 90, then losing 60, then gaining 100 see saw back and forth. Added up it was over 600lbs just in big swings of 40lbs or more.

Oh, and most of it was on a severely calorie restricted diet. At one point I was eating under 1200 calories a day, at over 400lbs, and I was still gaining weight; because my metabolic rate had fallen to well under 1/2 normal caloric burn per pound per day, and because I was retaining ever more water (eventually to the point it threatened my heart, breathing, blood pressure, and circulation in my hands and feet; never mind the great deal of pain it caused).

In early 2011, after 7 different doctors in 3 states over more than 6 years; we finally figured out what I had...

It was thyroid cancer.

Of course, I had been tested for thyroid problems, multiple times in fact; and my results were always inconsistent  Sometimes very high, sometimes very low, sometimes things that should be high when other things were high were low etc... etc...

But none of the blood tests were consistent with thyroid cancer.

I'd had head MRI, chest MRI, abdominal MRI, contrast on all of them, pet scans, cat scans, ultrasounds; in fact multiples of all of them... But because my blood tests weren't consistent with thyroid cancer, they'd never scanned for thyroid cancer, or even FELT my neck.

My endocrinologist saved my life, because he (and his PA) were the first to say "well, sometimes the blood tests are wrong, let's just check anyway".

They found what, at the time, was a potato sized tumor in my neck.

The other weird symptoms were side effects of the wild fluctuations in thyroid function, from paraneoplastic syndrome caused by the thyroid cancer, from microlesions all over my endocrine system making it nuts (which were also thrown off by the thyroid tumor); and from my body attempting to deal with all of it... very unsuccessfully.

Great, I finally had a diagnosis, and we knew how to treat it. Even better, there were ways to address the symptoms even before we got the cancer out.

The theory was that once we got the big main mass out, the other issues would either be easily treatable, or may even go away on their own.

BUT... they wanted me to wait a while before we went after the big tumor.

Because I had gained so much weight, my care team wanted me to lose over 140lbs before we removed the big tumor; to reduce the risk of death or serious side effects on the operating table.

140lbs is a lot of weight to lose; and I had been GAINING weight for years even on diets...

Initially, they offered me a gastric bypass; but I wasn't really happy with that idea. I was pretty sure that with the right medications helping me control my hormones and water weight, I could do it.

So I did it...

Once we figured out what was wrong, we were able to get me on a BIG STUPID PILE of medications  (including biweekly hormone injections, and literally dozens of pills a day) that allowed me to get rid of a lot of my ridiculous water retention, and start getting my metabolic rate back into something approaching a reasonable range.

With the medications, I was able to lose 153lbs in about 14 months; but my weight wouldn't stabilize. I would fluctuate as much as 60lbs up or down in a week or two. So my care team debated what to do for a few months; my endocrinologist wanting to do the surgery as soon as possible, and my oncological surgeon wanting to hold off on more weight loss and my weight stabilizing.

Finally, my endocrinologist, the leader of my care team, decided to get another ultrasound on my tumor; and it's good that he did, because he found that it had more than doubled in size and volume in the 12 months since my previous ultrasound.

At that point, he asked my surgeon to operate, but she still insisted that we stabilize my weight... So we found another surgeon.

That was the end of June. I had my surgical consult in mid July, and got scheduled for surgery in mid-August (the first slot the surgeon was able to get me into).

August 13th I had my tumor, as well as my whole thyroid removed (though they were able to save both parathyroids), in a surgery that took more than twice as long as expected... Because the tumor had grown even larger just in the six weeks since the ultrasound.

When they finally took the tumor out, it was a 10.2cm rough sphere (about 4"); and with the blood and thyroid included, the total mass removed was almost SIX POUNDS.

They got the pathology report back after the surgery, and I met with my surgeon, who told me that it was very lucky they had got it when they did, because if they hadn't I would likely only have had a few months before it was critical (could have killed me).

According to the pathology, this was an extremely aggressive malignancy (which we suspected given the growth rate of course), and that while there appeared to be no lymphocytic involvement, there was extensive vascular infiltration. Given the size, mass, and nature of the malignancy; along with the other symptoms (microlesions etc...), I would need to undergo aggressive radiation therapy, and a full body scan to check for other masses etc...

I knew this was a possibility, so I was preparing for Radioactive Ablative Iodine (RAI) therapy from day one. I have been on a mostly low iodine diet, and have not taken any thyroid supplementation, since two weeks before my surgery.

As soon as we got the lab results back, I went on an ultra low iodine diet, and tested my thyroid levels...  (they look for a TSH of at least 30, and over 40 is preferred. 9 days after surgery I was at 40, 20 days after surgery I was at 70) such that I was ready to take my first radiation treatment one month from my surgery (the minimum time allowed by protocol).

The various and sundry details, setbacks, annoyances, discoveries and whatnot have all been written about in fairly great detail in these pages these past two years; and are roughly indexed in this link:

http://anarchangel.blogspot.com/search/label/Cancer

And now, you're caught up to present day, at 2pm

At just about 1400 pacific today, a very nice guy named Bobby, very carefully (and thankfully very patient in letting me take some pictures) unscrewed a small shielded vessel containing a small sealed bottle, which he then unsealed and stepped back from:






After letting me take my pictures, he then very carefully put a small bluish white capsule containing a 150 millicurie equivalent dose of Iodine-131 onto my tongue, and had me swallow it.

After I finished the paperwork, I just randomly stood in the room near his dose calibrator, and it showed 85 microcuries from about four feet away (I cropped in on it in this pic):



With the probe just over my gullet (but not touching), his calibrated dosimeter registered me at 160 millirems per hour (which is also 1600 microsieverts per hour).

That's 1.6 times the Nuclear Regulatory Commissions (NRC) dosage limit for non-radiation workers for entire YEAR,  as an hourly dose rate. So, Yay!


Remember, that's not what's inside me (which is much more), it's what I'd be irradiating someone else who was standing right up against me.

I'm really glad I took the opportunity to ride my motorcycle down to the clinic. It was an absolutely amazingly beautiful day; high 70's, breezy and clear... Just beautiful, especially on a bike. It makes the 75 miles actually enjoyable, rather than a chore.

It couldn't have been a more amazing day, and I took the extra long and scenic ways home; stopped by the lake a while, then rode off deep into the woods away from everything where I knew there was a view, and just enjoyed it; because that's likely the last chance I'm going to get to take a lovely ride on a nice sunny day for a while.

I did notice one thing though; the GPS on my phone lost track when I touched it. Not surprising since, the tiny GPS antennae in the phone isn't exactly robust, and a VERY small amount of interference is all it takes to glitch one. It was only while I was actually touching the case though, as soon as I left it alone in its mount it was fine.

I was hoping that there'd be enough beta excitation to make my watch hands glow brighter; but it certainly wasn't evident in daylight even holding my hands up around the face to darken it up.... I'll try it again later, and it doesn't take all the much beta for a phosphor reaction; but I'm guessing there won't be much if anything noticeable.

Yesterday we got our radioactive dosimeter (RADEX 1706), and calibrated it to our local daytime and nighttime background radiation, which varied from 0.12-0.16 uSv/h day, and 0.08-0.10 uSv/h night; depending on where we measured, what time of day etc...

Basically, across 10 long baseline measurements (long baseline being 4x the 26 second short baseline acquisition time; or 104 seconds each), across 12 hours day and night, the baseline background radiation here is 0.12uSv/h; which is almost exactly 1/2 the national average; and unusually, is 1/3 the statewide average of neighboring Washington state.

Of course, that's still damn near nothing; it's about the same dosage of radiation you get from eating a banana.

Wait what, bananas are radioactive? AHHHH WE"RE ALL GONNA DIE!!!!

Or not...

EVERYTHING is radioactive; it's just a matter of how much.

Bananas have a large amount of potassium. Potassium naturally has a small amount of radioactive potassium isotopes mixed in; enough to give you a 0.098 or about 0.1 microsievert dose of radiation.

So, for those geniuses who constantly spout off about non-ionizing radiation, and how "there is no safe dose of radiation" etc...

Yeah, you're an idiot. Sorry.

When I got back home, I had Mel go to the gate with the meter and check when it hit 50, and then 100 microsieverts per hour... Which was about 35 and 25 feet away respectively.

Then had her walk up to the main floor and scan as I went by down to the basement (so she didn't have to get any closer for any further exposure). From a few feet inside the house, it peaked at around 80 uSv/h as I walked about 15 feet from the front door.


You might note, all that weight I lost? The 153lbs? Yeah, with the hypothyroid and the being off the meds for now about two months etc... All but 50lbs of it is back.

I've gained 40lbs since the surgery alone (and that's after losing 20 in the few days after the surgery); most of that in water. I feel like an overfilled water balloon.

 I can't wait until I can get back on my meds, and get my thyroid supplementation up (400mcg... rather a big difference from zero); and start losing weight again. Oh, even with the nausea I probably won't be losing any weight during radiation, because of the thyroid thing. My metabolism is so suppressed I can't keep my hands or feet warm; and my water retention is through the roof.

So, the rest of the post I've decided we're better off without pics, and we'll be talking about some bodily functions....

About the time I got home, the headache and nausea started coming on; and have been steadily coming on since.

Also, I was drinking mass quantities (as I had been advised to do; and I decided to test out one of the things all the websites tell you is a big safety issue... Just how much radiation you "pass out with water" so to speak.

I was... shocked.

From the seat, my ...liquid elimination... showed an effective dosage of 300 uSv/h; and that was before the full uptake (apparently it's going to rise further during the night; and may continue rising til tomorrow). Even after one flush, it was 80 uSv/h, and two it was 24...

Damn...

The docs told me that the more I could eliminate, the faster the radiation would come down to safe levels, the fewer side effects I'd have. They say that once per hour is ideal, but I should be going for at least once every two hours (which is about what I've been doing).

So then I ran some distance tests; and again, the engineer in me is amazed at how little attenuation there is from my body, the couch, the table in front of me etc... They're nearly transparent. I knew they would be of course, on the general "nuclear" scale... but we're talking about some very small amounts of radioactive material, with a comparatively very low energy isotope.

When I first got home, and sat myself in my normal position in the basement, Mels normal position on the main floor was below 10 uSv/h, but only just (9); and that's with about a 30 foot slant range, a floor and ceiling, and a bunch of furniture in between.

Touching the meter, holding it out at arms length, I was over 1000uSv/h (the max detection on my meter in that ranging), so I didn't bother checking the rating touching my abdomen. 3 feet away at the other end of the couch from my normal basement seating position was at 800 uSv/h. Six feet away was 600 uSv/h, and 12 feet was 480 uSv/h.

Honestly, these numbers all really surprised me. I really wasn't expecting that high... and they actually are high enough that with a few hours exposure, they could measurably increase someones rate of cancer or having children with birth defects.

Of course, that also means they increase my chances of other cancers; but since I've already got cancer that could kill me if I don't do it... That's the way it works.

Oh and never mind the fact that they didn't follow inverse square all that well; life isn't a physics problem, and atmosphere isn't vacuum.

The good news, is that the numbers are going down fast.

A note on rounding:
For these measurement, my meter can display 3 digits (internally it calculates to four decimal places) however, unless obviously otherwise, I am rounding as follows (always rounding up):
  • 1000+ is off the scale
  • 26-1000 to the nearest higher 5
  • 10-25 to the nearest higher 1
  • 0-9.9 to the nearest higher .1

6pm

Two hours later at 6pm (four hours after the dose), I was still over 1000 uSv/h at arms length touch, but hopefully not too much, because it took 20 seconds to get there. 3ft was 400 uSv/h, 6ft was 200 uSv/h, 12 ft was just 40 uSv/h.

However, my second elimination test showed 600 uSv/h!!! yipes.

8pm

I ran another series at 8pm, (six hours after dose), and I was finally below 1000uSv/h at arms length touch (850 uSv/h), 3ft was 200 uSv/h, 6ft was 80 uSv/h, and 12ft was 30 uSv/h

Third elimination test, another 610 uSv/h.

At 8, I also had Mel run the floor test, and now her seating position is only getting about 3 uSv/h; which is well below the safe threshold for reasonably long exposures ( 5 uSv/h) for pregnant women. So we're good with our current arrangements of things.

10pm 

Now as I write this it's 10pm, and I've got to say, the nausea and wooziness/woogieness is a bit much... The fatigue and ache and lack of body temp control from being severely hypothyroid are just WAY worse... But I'm not losing it or anything. I had dinner an hour ago and I'm holding it down no problem.

Also, I've been sucking on candies, and drinking a lot of sports drink and OJ, as is recommended to help elimination and to avoid salivary gland problems.

Seems to be working.

Let me just run my next test series...

Ok, arms length touch was 600 uSv/h, but I was still over 1000 uSv/h at my torso. I have to move out 12" to get below 1000 uSv/h. 3 ft out was 130 uSv/h, 6ft was 40 uSv/h, and 12ft was 25 uSv/h; with elimination at 520 uSv/h

I'll probably be awake 'til 2am, and if I am I'll update at midnight and 2am as well; to get a 12 hour baseline on the radiation.

Tomorrow, once I wake up, I'm going to switch to a 4 hour measurement cycle. I may stick at 4 hour, or go to six hours on Saturday.  I'm spreadsheeting all this data, and at the end of this I'm going to graph out the radiation dosage and distance over time.

Midnight update:

Well, the rate of reduction is reducing; as would be expected of course, though the slope isn't particularly consistent.

It was still more than a foot from my torso to get under 1000 uSv/h; and the arms length measurement had only dropped to about 535 uSv/h. The 3ft dropped to 110 uSv/h, the 6ft to 35 uSv/h, and the 12 ft measurement dropped to 22 uSv/h. The elimination test showed 480 uSv/h.

12hr update:

So, 2am, 12 hours after the initial dose, and here we go.

It's still more than a foot from my torso to get under 1000 uSv/h; and the arms length measurement  dropped to about 485 uSv/h. The 3ft dropped to 90 uSv/h, the 6ft to 30 uSv/h, and the 12 ft measurement dropped to 18 uSv/h. The elimination test dropped to 320 uSv/h.

One thing I've noticed, is that once you drop down below 500-600 uSv/h, the radiation dosage is HIGHLY directional; with my sides radiating about 2/3 the energy of my front, and my back radiating about half... Interesting.

I'm sure folks have done this in labs many many times; but I couldn't find it online anywhere; and it's the kind of data I wanted to see and understand when I was doing my research on this cancer, and this therapy so... Here it all is.

Tomorrow etc...

I'll be doing the following days radiation measurements one post per day. Haven't decided if I'll post in the morning and update during the day, or I'll just post it at the end of the night.

Paging Dr. Bruce Banner

I am gamma hot. Registered 90 millicuries just standing there. Their dosimeter read me at 160mRem just after taking the pill.

Pics and details to follow, but I thought Id post that before I ride home.

I bet im the only radioactive biker in the northwest this afternoon...

Nuke-u-lar Wessels?

So, in a few minutes I'm off to the nuclear medicine clinic for my first radiation treatment.

They're letting me do my isolation at home at least, so I'm not stuck in the hospital for four or five days; but I do have to drive down there and back alone; since Mel won't be able to sit in a car with me for at least a week.

ACtually... It's a gorgeous day, and I'm probably not going to feel well enough for a while... maybe not 'til after the weather turns... I think I'm going to ride the bike down. It may be my last chance.

There's likely to be some unpleasant side effects, and I'm probably going to feel pretty sick for at least the next few days... maybe more... So don't expect much in the way of good content.

However, we have a geiger counter/dosimeter, and a couple of experiments to run; maybe some videos of me making watches glow very brightly etc... to post.

This is likely the only time I will get to be radioactive on purpose, and if you think I'm going to miss making the jokes, and running the experiments, and screwing with stuff over it... You don't know me too well do you?

Wednesday, September 12, 2012

Overnight last night

We hit freezing for the first time this season. Officially it was 34, but we saw 32 here.

... My instinct keeps saying "this year" not "this season"; but of course, the last time we were below freezing was in early April this year (looked it up; there was an overnight freeze april 14th, but it had been over freezing for most of a couple weeks before that)...

So, we put our first fire of the season in the fireplace this morning; cleared out the flu, took the chill off the morning, and then we let it burn down; before it hit a high of 73 today.

It's been unusually cold overnight for the last few nights, dropping from the high 40s (and even low 50s two weeks ago), to the mid-low 30s. It should be right around freezing (forecast is 33) tonight as well; then it should be back in the mid-low 40s overnight for the next couple weeks (the normal overnight temps for this time of year. It normally doesn't average under freezing overnight 'til late October).

Amazing that four weeks ago it was in the mid 90s. Seasons change faster here than they did where I grew up in New England. Probably something to do with the maritime climate, and the big thermal mass of the ocean there, vs. the mountains (the big lake can't quite match up to the north atlantic).

We've got two cords of two year seasoned birch out back waiting to be neatly racked and stacked by our upstairs and downstairs doors.

One or two small splits in our fireplace insert does a pretty good job of taking a 35 degree outside to a 75 degree inside.

If we have as mild a winter this year as we did last year, two cords should be more than enough for the winter without needing to use the oil heaters at all.

It's good them temps will be going back up, since I start sleeping in the basement tomorrow. Mel and I will both miss the body heat with each other.

Accountability, responsibility, risk, metrics, unions, markets... What about education?

Right now, Chicago teachers are striking, even though they already make an average salary nearly double that of the average Chicago family, and are being offered a 16% raise over four years.

I dunno about you, but as a free market partcipant in our economy today, that sounds like a pretty good deal.

Well, first thing is they're asking for a 30% raise over four years... but that's really just a negotiating point, and one they don't expect to get. If it were just about the raise, I'd guess they'd take the 16%.

It's not.

It's not really about the money; it's that the teachers new contract attempts, in even the tiniest way, to add some accountability and performance measures to the teachers contracts.

... and the teachers unions can't give even a millimeter on this issue. Not one millimeter, not ever. Because if they do, their rigid seniority system collapses, and they lose power.

Here's a fun fact; a lot of younger teachers don't mind the idea of performance standards, and they actually LIKE the idea of merit pay, performance bonueses etc... It's not a foreign idea for them, because all their friends who live in the real world market economy have that sort of thing.

Recently, in Idaho, the commissioner of education managed to get teacher tenure eliminated, and performance based bonuses (note, not performance based salaries or hiring or firing, just bonuses) passed as commission regulations, and then when they were challenged in lawsuits, via statute approved by public referendum.

In response, the teachers unions sponsored an unsuccessful attempt to have the commissioner (who is now serving as one of the two lead advisors on education to the Romney campaign) recalled. So unsuccessful in fact the numbers indicate basically no-one voted for the recall but teachers and their immediate families.

This year, they managed to get enough signatures together to get a repeal effort on the merit pay rules on the ballot as a referendum; polling on which indicates it will fail miserably. Meanwhile, the teachers unions are both suing to prevent the policies from being implemented AND SIMULTANEOUSLY suing to force the department of education to distribute the bonus money, but on a seniority basis.

Trying to have their cake and eat it too.

I don't understand how much more clear it could be that this has nothing to do with the wellbeing of our children, or about good teachers; it's about protecting union rules, and union rule...

BUT, there are certainly good, well meaning people, who really do believe that we shouldn't put performance standards on teachers... That it's somehow "unfair" or impossible, or just not a good idea etc...

"You can't hold teachers accountable for the performance of their students, there's too much they can't control. Their home lives, their parents, poverty... Good teachers could be penalized simply for having bad students). It's not fair"

Common refrain from teachers, and from those who support their position in this... After all you wouldn't want to be evaluated on someone elses efforts and abilities right?

Well... I am. Most likely you are too.

In the free market, we are held accountable for other people performance and decisions etc... all the time.

As an individual contributor, my performance is measured not only by my own efforts, abilities, and success; but that of my group, my manager, and my company as a whole.

As a manager, I am held entirely accountable for someone elses performance. I have tools to motivate them, help them perform better etc... But still, I have to deal with the performance that other people give me. I have to have the skill to use that performance in the best possible way.

"But you can fire your low performing employees".

Really?

Ever worked in corporate America? Or had a real job of any kind?

So long as my employees meet bare minimum standards, and don't actually commit a crime (or violate major HR policies), I'm not getting rid of my low performers. It's up to me, to make them meet the standards I need for my group to be successful.

In sales, you are held accountable for other people actions, decisions, and performance as well. You don't get to control your customers decisions, and how much they buy from you is dependent more on their performance than yours.

Yes, a skilled salesperson with a good support team will sell more than an unskilled one; and that's as it should be... but its still entirely dependent on someone elses performance and decisions. A good sales guy can't get a customer who doesn't have the money for the product, to buy the product... or at least not more than once.

Good sales managers understand this. They set account and territory sales expectations based on a reasonable evaluation of the possible performance of those accounts. If they don't then they won't get any decent sales people to work for them, and they'll constantly churn sales people making these accounts and territories perform even worse.

What matters in evaluating your ability as a salesperson isn't your absolute sales, it's your performance in comparison to other sales people with a similar situation. IF you perform well, then good managers will put you on difficult accounts that have the potential to perform better, and reward you if you make them perform up to potential.

At least if you have a decent management team.

At that point you're at the mercy of having a good boss, who understands that relative performance is a better judge of your capability than absolute performance...

Just like teachers.

Holding teachers accountable, doesn't mean that all teachers should be held to arbitrary and universal standards. Teachers that teach all "remedial" students can't be held to the same standard of performance as those who teach all honors students...

And NO-ONE IS SUGGESTING ANYTHING LIKE THAT.

Or at least no-one serious, with credibility, who should be listened to.

Calling for "standardized testing and accountability" isn't calling for teachers to make poor students perform at the level of honors students. It's calling for teachers of all levels of students to perform no worse than average against other teachers of similar levels of students; and to measure improvement in those students over time, compared to other teachers of the same level of students.

How is that unreasonable?

Only those with the irrational... even stupid... belief that teaching is some kind of special "calling" performed only by special people who must be protected from the market forces that the rest of us must cope with; could possibly justify that sort of thinking, with any kind of intellectual honesty.

They generally apply the same sort of thinking to artists, who must be protected from the horrible taste of the masses etc...

Yeah... If we did that, then teachers would be at the mercy of having competent managers, who knew how to evaluate performance.

Just like the rest of us.

In fact... The only time I ever see a serious proposal that teachers should be evaluated by absolute and arbitrary standards... It's coming from lefties or teachers; because they are trying to "avoid bias" or "avoid subjectivity" etc... etc... etc...

Holding teachers accountable also means holding administrators and school systems accountable. It means making them participate in the market that the rest of us are forced to.

If you have a poorly managed school, good teachers won't go there.

IF good teachers won't go there, then good students won't go there... IF they're given the option that is...

Oh... wait a second... Hey... that might just be...

And of course, if we allowed that, then the unions would lose...

Oh... hey, that might just be...

Ya think maybe...

Teaching is a job, just like any other. It's a job that has more benefits than most. These days, it's even a job that pays more than most. It's a job that has a lot more security than most. It's a job that has more garbage and BS and heartbreak than most. It's a job that's harder than most. It's a job that's a lot more important than most...

Great teachers can do more to help children be successful than anything other than great parents...

But it's still a job.

Teachers aren't superheroes, they aren't artists, they are workers... just like the rest of us.

Teachers don't need to be protected from the real world, they need to be a part of it, and accountable to it... just like the rest of us.

Maybe if they were, there would be a lot more good teachers, and a lot less bad ones.

Maybe if they our were, our children would be a lot better off.